knitting: Batman Beyond Scarf

[jamjar]

So, having made all of two scarves before hand, I decided to try designing my own. being moderately fannish obsessed, I decided on a Batman Beyond scarf. I wanted to attempt illusion knitting/shadow knitting (when you can only see the patten if you look at it from a specific angle), and the batsymbol seemed a logical choice for this.

This particular WIP has taught me the importance of row counters, and the best way to roll wool up into a ball after you've had to unravel it. Many and varied are the mistakes I made, even after I fugured out how to do the damn thing, which I'll try and sort out when it's done.

I started by tracing the symbol on to actual-size knitting graph paper.
First, I tried the symbol going horizontally along the scarf:
From above



From below


Wrong side


But the symbol didn't really seem big enough, or clear enough, so I unravelled it (both fun and soul-destroying!) and got girl_starfish to draw it vertically on the graph paper, so I could make it twice as big.

From above:



From the side



From the other side:



Wrong side:





Quick poll, except lj doesn't seem to be letting me make polls right now: Which is best for the rest of the scarf:

Vertical symbol going up the scarf (and facing all the same direction, or alternating?)
Vertical symbol on the ends, smaller horizontal one going along the scarf.
Plain, flat stockinette stripes, with the symbol only done once on each end.
Raised-red, flat black stripes, and the symbol only done once on each end.
Raised-black, flat red stripes, and the symbol only done once on each end.

Pattern available on request, for them as wants it.